Limited-time introductory pricing — save up to 50%. Start free →
PointFactors
Sign in

Point Factor vs Factor Comparison: Which Job Evaluation Method Fits Your Jobs?

Date Published

Title card for point factor vs factor comparison, contrasting job scores in points with job scores in money.

Point Factor vs Factor Comparison: Which Job Evaluation Method Fits Your Jobs?

The point factor method and the factor comparison method are the two quantitative ways to evaluate jobs. Both break a job into compensable factors such as skill, responsibility and working conditions. Both produce a number. And both promise a more defensible answer than ranking jobs by gut feel.

They differ in one way that changes everything: what the number is. A point factor plan scores jobs in points against a fixed scale. A factor comparison plan scores jobs in money, using what you pay a set of key jobs today. That one design choice drives how easy each method is to build, explain, maintain and defend.

This guide puts point factor vs factor comparison side by side. You will see how each method works, the same fictional job scored both ways, the strengths and weaknesses of each, and a simple way to decide which one fits your organization.

TL;DR

  • Both methods score jobs factor by factor. Point factor outputs points; factor comparison outputs money.
  • Factor comparison builds its scale from current pay of key jobs, so it can carry today's pay problems forward.
  • Point factor scales use defined degree levels, which makes them easier to explain, audit and keep current.
  • Most organizations that want a quantitative method today choose point factor and price grades with market data.

Point factor vs factor comparison at a glance

Here is the short version before the detail. The two methods share the same starting idea, factor-based analysis, but they build the measuring stick differently.

Table comparing point factor vs factor comparison on output, scale source, factors, pay bias risk and ease of explanation.

Caption: Point factor vs factor comparison at a glance, comparing output, scale, factors, pay bias risk and ease of explanation.


Point factor

Factor comparison

Output

Points, converted to grades

Money rates per factor

Scale built from

Defined degree levels

Current pay of key jobs

Number of factors

Typically 4–10

Usually 5

Pay bias risk

Lower

Higher (inherits current pay)

Ease of explanation

High

Low

Typical use today

Common

Rare

The 1969 International Labour Review survey of white-collar job evaluation in the United States found point rating plans were "by far the more numerous," and described point plans as using between four and ten factors (ILO, Kress 1969). That gap has only grown since.

How the point factor method works

The point factor method measures every job against the same written scale. You build the scale once, then score each job against it.

The build has four steps:

  • Choose your factors. Most plans use skill, effort, responsibility and working conditions, with sub-factors under each. See our guide to compensable factors.
  • Weight the factors. Decide how much each factor matters, for example skill at 40% of total points. Our guide to compensable factor weighting covers the methods.
  • Write degree levels. Each factor gets a ladder of levels, each with a plain-language definition and a point value.
  • Convert points to grades. Add the points, then group point ranges into grades. Our guide to turning job evaluation points into pay grades walks through it.

The U.S. federal government uses this logic at scale. Its Factor Evaluation System uses nine factors with set point values. Classifiers select the proper level for each factor, add the points and read the grade from a point-grade conversion table (OPM, Introduction to the Position Classification Standards).

The key point: the scale has nothing to do with what you pay today. Pay comes later, when you attach market data to each grade. That separation is what makes point factor plans easy to defend.

How the factor comparison method works

The factor comparison method was developed by Eugene Benge in the 1920s and set out in detail in Benge, Burk and Hay's 1941 Manual of Job Evaluation. A 1943 U.S. War Manpower Commission manual called it "a modification of the Point System," also known as the Key Job System, in its Informational Manual, Industrial Job Evaluation Systems.

It runs in five steps:

  • Pick key jobs. A committee selects roughly 10 to 25 benchmark jobs whose pay everyone agrees is fair.
  • Use five factors. The classic set is mental requirements, skill, physical requirements, responsibility and working conditions.
  • Rank key jobs on each factor. Committee members rank every key job, factor by factor, then pool the rankings.
  • Split each key job's pay across the factors. A key job paid $24.00 an hour might get $7.20 for mental requirements, $6.00 for skill, and so on, until the parts add up to the full rate.
  • Slot other jobs. For each factor, you compare a new job with the key jobs and give it the money value of the closest match. The factor values add up to the job's rate.

The ranking and the money split should agree. When they do not, the 1943 manual says jobs with large discrepancies are thrown out of the key job list. That check is useful, but it also shows how much judgment sits inside the method.

The same job, scored both ways

Abstract comparisons only go so far. Here is one fictional job, a Payroll Specialist, evaluated with each method. All figures are a fictional example.

Fictional Payroll Specialist scored with point factor vs factor comparison: 530 points versus a $27.60 hourly rate.

Caption: A fictional Payroll Specialist scored with point factor vs factor comparison, showing points against money rates.

Factor comparison. The key job Payroll Clerk is paid $24.00 an hour. The committee splits that rate: mental requirements $7.20, skill $6.00, physical requirements $2.40, responsibility $6.00, working conditions $2.40. The total is $24.00.

The Payroll Specialist needs more judgment, more skill and carries more responsibility. Comparing it factor by factor with the key jobs gives: mental $8.40, skill $7.20, physical $2.40, responsibility $7.20, working conditions $2.40. That adds up to $27.60 an hour.

Point factor. The plan has 1,000 total points: skill 400, effort 150, responsibility 350, working conditions 100. Each factor has five degree levels, and each level earns an equal share of the factor's points.

Factor

Max points

Degree

Points

Skill

400

3 of 5

240

Effort

150

2 of 5

60

Responsibility

350

3 of 5

210

Working conditions

100

1 of 5

20

Total

1,000


530

With grade 6 set at 500 to 549 points, the job lands in grade 6. You then price grade 6 with market data.

Notice the difference. The factor comparison answer, $27.60, depends entirely on what you already pay the Payroll Clerk. If that rate is too low, every job slotted against it inherits the error. The point factor answer, 530 points, stays valid no matter what happens to pay rates. If the market moves, you reprice grade 6. You do not re-evaluate the job.

Want to see how this scoring looks in practice? Book a short PointFactors demo and we will score one of your jobs live.

Strengths and weaknesses of each method

Point factor: strengths

  • Easy to explain. Managers and employees can read the degree definitions and see why a job scored what it did.
  • Stable. Scores stay valid when market rates change. Only the pay attached to each grade moves.
  • Consistent across job families. One scale can measure a nurse, an engineer and a payroll specialist.
  • Audit-friendly. Each score traces back to written definitions, which supports internal equity reviews and gender-neutral job evaluation.

Point factor: weaknesses

  • Up-front design work. Writing clear factor and degree definitions takes time.
  • Weights involve judgment. The 1943 manual noted that point weights rest on the judgment of whoever builds the plan. Testing weights against benchmark jobs reduces that risk.

Factor comparison: strengths

  • Built-in pay link. Results come out in money, so the method connects directly to wage rates.
  • Fits your own jobs. The scale is built from your organization's key jobs, not a generic template.

Factor comparison: weaknesses

  • Inherits current pay. If key jobs are underpaid, for example in roles held mostly by women, the scale bakes that gap in. The 1969 ILO review was blunt: using actual salaries to build a rating scale "is unsound."
  • Slow and hard to run. The same review called the method "unwieldy, slow and uncertain."
  • Goes stale. Each pay increase or market shift can undermine the money values, so the scale needs constant rework.
  • Hard to explain. Telling an employee that their job earns $2.40 for working conditions invites debate about the money, not the job.

Where Hay and Mercer fit

Edward Hay was one of the three authors of the 1941 manual. His firm later developed the Guide Chart-Profile Method, now owned by Korn Ferry. Despite its roots in factor comparison, the Hay method is a point-factor variant: jobs earn points on know-how, problem solving and accountability. Mercer's IPE is also a point-factor variant. For a detailed side-by-side, see our Hay vs Mercer IPE comparison.

In other words, the market voted. The best-known proprietary methods kept factor analysis but moved from money to points.

How to choose between point factor and factor comparison

For most organizations the choice is simple. Use this test:

  • Choose point factor if you need to explain results to employees, support pay equity or pay transparency work, cover many job families, or keep scores valid through market changes. That covers most employers today.
  • Consider factor comparison only if you have a small, stable set of jobs, trusted current pay rates with no known equity issues, and a team with time to maintain money values every cycle.

If you are still weighing the other two classic methods, our guide to the 4 methods of job evaluation compares ranking, classification, factor comparison and point factor in one place.

A practical middle path: borrow factor comparison's best idea, the key job check, inside a point factor plan. Score your benchmark jobs first, then confirm the point order matches how your committee sees the jobs. If a benchmark lands out of order, fix the definitions, not the pay.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between point factor and factor comparison?

The point factor method scores jobs in points against defined degree levels. The factor comparison method scores jobs in money, by splitting the pay of key jobs across factors. Points are converted to grades and priced separately; factor comparison produces a wage rate directly.

Is factor comparison still used?

Rarely. It survives in a few legacy plans and in textbooks. Most organizations that want a quantitative method use a point factor plan, including the Hay and Mercer IPE variants.

Is the Hay method factor comparison?

No. Hay's Guide Chart-Profile Method grew out of factor comparison, but it scores jobs in points, so it is a point-factor variant.

Which method is better for pay equity?

Point factor. Because its scale does not depend on current pay, it does not carry existing pay gaps into the evaluation. That makes it easier to show that jobs of equal value are paid equally.

How many factors does each method use?

Classic factor comparison plans use five factors. Point factor plans typically use four to ten factors, often with sub-factors under each.

Can I convert a factor comparison plan to point factor?

Yes. Keep your factors and key jobs, write degree definitions for each factor, assign point values, then re-score the key jobs and check the order. Our job evaluation questionnaire guide helps you collect the job data you need.

Score jobs on points, not yesterday's pay

Point factor gives you the rigor of factor comparison without tying every score to what you pay today. PointFactors uses AI to score each job against your compensable factors, documents the evidence behind every degree level, and converts points to grades you can defend. Book a demo to see PointFactors score your jobs.

By Justin Hampton, founder and CEO of PointFactors.

Join the PointFactors newsletter

One email a month on job evaluation, pay equity and pay transparency. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.

Work email required. By joining you agree to receive our monthly newsletter; see our Privacy Policy.

Book a live demo

Open the scheduler in a new tab