From PDQ to Pay Band: A Worked Point-Factor Example
Date Published

From PDQ to Pay Band: A Worked Point-Factor Example
Most guides tell you to collect a PDQ and then "evaluate the job." They skip the part you actually need: what do you do with the form once it is in your hands? How does a paragraph about month-end payroll turn into a pay band?
This article walks one fictional position through PDQ job evaluation from start to finish. You will see the PDQ evidence, the factor scores, the point total, the grade, and the pay band, with the arithmetic shown at every step. Every number is invented for the example, so swap in your own plan, grades, and market data.
It assumes you know what a position description questionnaire is. If you need the basics of the scoring method first, read our guide to the point-factor method.
TL;DR
- A PDQ documents the job. The committee turns that evidence into a degree on each compensable factor, adds the points, and places the job in a grade.
- In our fictional example, a Payroll Specialist scores 575 points on a 1,000-point plan and lands in Grade 6.
- A pay policy line turns the grade's midpoint points into a midpoint salary, and a spread turns that midpoint into a minimum and maximum.
- Every score should trace back to a sentence on the PDQ. If it does not, you are guessing.
The path from PDQ to pay band
The process has five steps. Each one produces a record the next step depends on, so you can audit the chain later.
- Read the completed PDQ. Check it for gaps and vague answers.
- Map the evidence to factors. Match what the form says to your compensable factors.
- Score each factor. Pick the degree that fits the evidence and record its points.
- Place the job in a grade. Add the points and find the grade that contains the total.
- Build the pay band. Use your pay policy line and range spread to set minimum, midpoint, and maximum.
The U.S. federal government uses this same chain for General Schedule jobs. In the Factor Evaluation System, a classifier assigns a level and its points for each of nine factors, adds them, and converts the total to a grade. Private employers use their own factors and tables, but the logic is the same.
The fictional plan we will use
We will use the five-factor, 1,000-point plan from our point factor scale examples. It looks like this.
Factor | Weight | Points by degree |
|---|---|---|
Knowledge and skills | 300 | 60, 120, 180, 240, 300 |
Problem solving | 200 | 40, 80, 120, 160, 200 |
Accountability for results | 250 | 50, 100, 150, 200, 250 |
Interpersonal contact | 150 | 35, 75, 115, 150 |
Working conditions | 100 | 10, 35, 65, 100 |
Knowledge, problem solving, and accountability each have five degrees. Contact and conditions have four. Degree 1 is the lowest in every factor.
Step 1: Read the PDQ
Here is an excerpt from a completed PDQ for a fictional Payroll Specialist. The incumbent wrote the duties and time estimates. The supervisor reviewed and agreed.
- Duties and time: Process biweekly payroll for 400 employees (50%). Reconcile payroll to the general ledger each month (20%). Answer employee pay questions (15%). Prepare quarterly tax filings (10%). Other duties (5%).
- Education and experience: Associate degree in accounting or equivalent, plus three years of payroll experience.
- Decisions: Resolves most pay discrepancies using payroll policy. Escalates exceptions to the Payroll Manager.
- Impact of errors: Errors can cause incorrect pay for employees and late tax filings. The Controller reviews the monthly reconciliation.
- Contacts: Works daily with employees and managers to explain pay. Works with the tax agency on notices.
- Work environment: Office setting, extended computer work.
Notice what the form does. It describes the job, not the person. It says what the position requires, not how well the current incumbent performs. That is the difference between job evaluation and performance evaluation.
Before you score, audit the form for the problems we cover in five PDQ mistakes. Here the percentages total 100% and the duties are specific, so the form is ready.
Step 2: Map the evidence to factors
Now match each piece of evidence to a factor. This table is your audit trail. If a committee member asks "why degree 3?", you point to the evidence column.
Factor | PDQ evidence | Degree chosen |
|---|---|---|
Knowledge and skills | Associate degree plus three years of payroll experience | 3 |
Problem solving | Resolves most discrepancies under policy, escalates exceptions | 3 |
Accountability for results | Pay accuracy for 400 employees, tax filings, reviewed by the Controller | 3 |
Interpersonal contact | Daily explanation of pay to employees, managers, and a tax agency | 3 |
Working conditions | Office setting, extended computer work | 1 |
The degree definitions come from your plan. Write them so each level has a clear test, as we explain in factor degree definitions. The committee, not the incumbent, picks the degree. Our guide to running a job evaluation committee covers how to keep that discussion consistent.
Step 3: Score and add the points
Look up the points for each chosen degree and add them.
Factor | Degree | Points |
|---|---|---|
Knowledge and skills | 3 | 180 |
Problem solving | 3 | 120 |
Accountability for results | 3 | 150 |
Interpersonal contact | 3 | 115 |
Working conditions | 1 | 10 |
Total | 575 |
The arithmetic: 180 + 120 = 300. Add 150 to get 450. Add 115 to get 565. Add 10 to get 575.
That is 57.5% of the 1,000 points available. Does that feel right for a payroll specialist? It sits above entry-level clerical work and below managers and senior analysts, which is where most comp professionals would place it. If it felt far off, you would revisit your degree choices before going further. A careless score at this stage flows into the grade and then the pay band.
If you want the full scoring toolkit, our job evaluation questionnaire guide covers the scoring side of the instrument.
Step 4: Place the job in a grade
Next, sort jobs into grades by their points. We covered how to find the natural breaks in your data in how to convert job evaluation points into pay grades. To keep this example simple, we use evenly spaced fictional grades.
Grade | Point range | Point midpoint |
|---|---|---|
5 | 401 to 500 | 450 |
6 | 501 to 600 | 550 |
7 | 601 to 700 | 650 |
At 575 points, the Payroll Specialist falls in Grade 6. The Grade 6 point midpoint is 550.
Real plans rarely use perfectly even grades. You would set boundaries at gaps in your scored jobs and test them against current pay. This table only shows the mechanics.
Step 5: Build the pay band
Now convert points to dollars. You need a pay policy line, which comes from market data for your benchmark jobs and your pay philosophy. Our fictional policy line is:
Pay = $95 × points + $18,000
Plug in the Grade 6 point midpoint:
- $95 × 550 = $52,250
- $52,250 + $18,000 = $70,250 midpoint
Then apply a range spread. We will use a 40% spread, which fits a traditional structure of 9 to 14 grades. Set the minimum at midpoint divided by 1.20 and the maximum at minimum times 1.40.
- Minimum: $70,250 ÷ 1.20 = $58,541.67, rounded to $58,540
- Maximum: $58,541.67 × 1.40 = $81,958.33, rounded to $81,960
Check the result. The midpoint of the band is ($58,540 + $81,960) ÷ 2 = $70,250, which matches. The spread is ($81,960 − $58,540) ÷ $58,540 = 40.0%. For more on setting midpoints, see how to set salary range midpoints.
So the Payroll Specialist's band is $58,540 to $81,960, with a midpoint of $70,250. Note that the band belongs to Grade 6, not to this one job. Every job that scores 501 to 600 points shares it.
PointFactors links the questionnaire, the factor scores, and the grade table, so a change to one degree updates the points, grade, and band instantly. Start free to see that chain on your own jobs.
Step 6: Test before you announce
A band is a draft until you test it. Run these checks before anything goes to employees.
- Rank check. Do jobs rank in the order your leaders expect? A manager who scores below the people they supervise signals a scoring error, not a surprise.
- Evidence check. Can you point to PDQ language for every degree? Anything you cannot trace goes back to the supervisor.
- Market check. Compare the band midpoint to market data for the same job. Our guide to market pricing vs job evaluation explains how to use both without letting either override the other.
- People check. Count employees below minimum or above maximum. Plan remediation before you communicate results.
Where this goes wrong
- Scoring the person. If you pick degrees based on how good the incumbent is, you are measuring performance. Score what the job requires.
- Copying PDQ language into degrees without a test. "Complex" and "significant" mean nothing until your degree definitions say what they mean.
- Skipping the audit trail. If you cannot show why a job got degree 3, you cannot defend it when an employee appeals.
- Letting pay set the points. If you score a job high because it pays high, the system loses its independence from market and history.
- Reusing the fictional numbers. The $95 slope and the 40% spread belong to this example. Your policy line and spread come from your own data.
FAQ
How do you use a PDQ in job evaluation?
The PDQ supplies the evidence. The evaluation committee reads it, picks a degree on each compensable factor, adds the points, and uses the total to place the job in a grade. Each degree should trace back to a statement on the form.
Does the incumbent decide the score?
No. The incumbent describes the job and the supervisor reviews it. The committee decides the degrees using your plan's definitions. This keeps the scoring consistent across jobs.
How many points does a job need to move up a grade?
It depends on your grade table. In our fictional example, each grade spans 100 points, so a job needs 601 points to reach Grade 7. Your boundaries should come from the natural gaps in your scored jobs.
How do you convert job evaluation points to a salary?
Fit a pay policy line to your benchmark jobs, then plug in each grade's midpoint points to get a midpoint salary. Apply a range spread to build the minimum and maximum. Our example uses a line of $95 per point plus $18,000, which is fictional.
What range spread should I use?
Traditional structures with 9 to 14 grades often use spreads around 40% to 50%, according to common practice. Narrower structures use less and broad structures use more. Choose the spread that fits your number of grades and promotion paths.
What if the score looks wrong after I add it up?
Go back to the evidence. Either a degree was chosen too high or too low, or the PDQ left out something that matters. Fix the data first. Never adjust points to reach a pay result you already want.
How long does it take to evaluate one job?
Once the PDQ is clean, a committee can often discuss a straightforward job in 15 to 30 minutes. Treat that as a planning estimate, not a standard, and expect new or unusual jobs to take longer.
Turn your PDQs into pay bands
A PDQ becomes a pay band through five steps: read the evidence, map it to factors, score the degrees, place the grade, and build the band. Keep a trace from every score back to the form, and the result holds up when someone challenges it.
PointFactors connects the PDQ, the scorecard, the grade table, and the pay band in one place, so your team spends its time on judgment instead of spreadsheets. Start free to run a real job through the chain, or review pricing.
Justin Hampton, founder and CEO of PointFactors, writes about job evaluation, pay structure, and compensation strategy for HR leaders and compensation analysts.
Join the PointFactors newsletter
One email a month on job evaluation, pay equity and pay transparency. No spam; unsubscribe anytime.